Bridge collapses are rare but catastrophic events that can lead to significant loss of life, serious injuries, and millions in property damage. These incidents often prompt questions of liability, especially when structural failures are involved. Identifying who is liable in the aftermath of a bridge collapse is complex and depends on several factors, including the cause of the collapse and the parties responsible for the construction, maintenance, and inspection of the structure.

Common Causes of Bridge Collapses

Before examining who may be liable, it's essential to review the typical causes of bridge collapses. These incidents often stem from multiple factors, including poor construction practices, inadequate maintenance, environmental factors, or accidents involving vehicles/boats.

Some of the most common causes of bridge collapses include:

• Structural Deficiencies: Over time, bridges can develop structural weaknesses due to poor initial design, the use of substandard materials, or age-related deterioration. If not addressed through regular maintenance and upgrades, these deficiencies can lead to collapses.
• Natural Disasters: Floods, earthquakes, and severe storms can compromise a bridge's foundation, leading to collapse. Bridges in areas prone to such events must be constructed to withstand environmental stress.
• Corrosion and Wear: Prolonged exposure to the elements can cause corrosion of metal components, weakening the structure. Regular inspections and timely repairs are necessary to prevent failures due to corrosion.
• Vehicle Impacts: In some cases, a bridge may collapse due to a significant impact from a heavy vehicle or a collision involving multiple vehicles. This can cause immediate structural damage or exacerbate existing weaknesses.
• Poor Maintenance: Bridges require regular inspections and maintenance to remain safe. When responsible parties neglect these duties, it can lead to disastrous consequences.

Determining Liability for a Bridge Collapse

Determining liability in a bridge collapse often involves examining the chain of responsibility, from the bridge's design and construction to its maintenance and inspection. Several parties can be held liable, depending on their role in the structure's lifecycle.

Construction Companies

The company that built the bridge may be held liable if evidence shows that faulty construction practices contributed to the collapse. This could include using substandard materials, failing to follow safety protocols, or deviating from the approved design plans.

Construction companies must adhere to strict building codes and standards to ensure public safety. If these standards were violated, resulting in a structurally unsound bridge, the construction company could face significant legal repercussions.

Design Engineers

Bridges are complex structures that require precise engineering to withstand various stresses. If the collapse results from a design flaw, such as incorrect calculations or failure to account for environmental factors, the engineers responsible for the bridge's design could be held accountable.

Design engineers are typically required to carry professional liability insurance to cover such incidents. However, proving design flaws as the cause of a collapse often requires extensive investigation and expert testimony.

Government Agencies

In many cases, government entities are responsible for maintaining and inspecting bridges, especially on public roads. A local, state, or federal agency may be liable if a collapse occurs due to a lack of adequate inspections or failure to address known structural issues.

For example, the National Bridge Inventory (NBI), maintained by the Federal Highway Administration, requires regular inspections of bridges in the United States. If an agency fails to conduct these inspections or ignores critical repairs, it may be held responsible for the collapse.

Private Owners or Operators

In some cases, bridges are owned or operated by private entities, such as toll road operators or private companies. These owners are responsible for maintaining the bridge and ensuring it meets safety standards. If a collapse occurs due to negligence, they may be held liable.

Third-Party Contractors

Contractors hired to perform maintenance, repairs, or inspections may also bear responsibility if their work is substandard or if they fail to identify critical structural issues. Third-party liability often arises when independent contractors do not meet the required safety standards.

Case Study: The Francis Scott Key Bridge Collapse

The collapse of the Francis Scott Key Bridge in Baltimore is a prime example of the complexities surrounding liability in such incidents. In this case, a section of the bridge gave way following a collision with a cargo ship. The lone survivor of the collapse described the terror of falling into the water and the emotional trauma that followed.

This incident highlights how multiple factors can contribute to a bridge collapse, including neglected maintenance and possible engineering deficiencies. Legal actions in such cases typically involve extensive investigations into the roles of construction companies, government agencies, and inspectors.

The Baltimore collapse also underscores the importance of holding responsible parties accountable to prevent future tragedies. In cases like these, victims may pursue compensation for medical expenses, lost income, pain and suffering, and other damages.

Seeking Compensation After a Bridge Collapse

Victims of bridge collapses often face life-altering injuries or even death, leading to significant emotional and financial burdens. Filing a personal injury or wrongful death lawsuit will help secure compensation to cover these expenses. Key considerations for pursuing legal action include:

• Identifying Liable Parties: As discussed, liability may fall on multiple parties. Legal experts will need to investigate the root causes of the collapse to determine who is responsible.
• Documenting Damages: Victims must thoroughly document medical expenses, lost wages, and other expenses related to the collapse.
• Expert Testimony: Bridge collapses often require expert testimony from engineers, construction specialists, and accident reconstruction professionals to build a strong case.

Conclusion

Determining liability in a bridge collapse is a complex process involving multiple parties and thorough investigations. Construction companies, design engineers, government agencies, and third-party contractors may all share responsibility depending on the circumstances of the collapse.

Need Legal Help? Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law is One Phone Call Away

Navigating personal injury claims can be challenging. Fortunately, you don't need to do it alone. The experienced personal injury lawyers at Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law, are available 24/7 to help you understand your legal options, gather necessary evidence, and build a strong case to secure the settlement you deserve.
Contact us now for a free legal review.