In the realm of personal injury law, the term "negligence per se" plays a pivotal role in establishing liability in certain cases. Negligence per se refers to a legal doctrine where an individual's violation of a law, statute, or regulation is considered inherently negligent. This concept streamlines the plaintiff's burden of proof by focusing on the breach of legal duty rather than requiring extensive evidence to show that the defendant acted unreasonably. Understanding the nuances of negligence per se is key for anyone pursuing a personal injury claim.
Defining Negligence Per Se
Negligence per se arises when a defendant's conduct violates a statute or regulation designed to protect a specific group of people from a particular type of harm. Unlike traditional negligence claims, which require proving the defendant's actions were unreasonable, negligence per se assumes negligence when the following elements are met:
Statutory Violation:
The defendant broke a law or regulation.
Intent of the Law:
The violated law was enacted to prevent the type of harm suffered by the plaintiff.
Plaintiff's Protection:
The law was designed to protect a specific group of people, including the plaintiff.
Causation:
The violation of the law directly caused the plaintiff's injury.
For instance, if a driver runs a red light and causes an accident, they may be considered negligent per se because traffic laws are designed to protect others on the road from accidents caused by such behavior.
Examples of Negligence Per Se
Negligence per se can apply in a variety of situations, particularly where safety laws or regulations are involved. Common examples include:
- Traffic Violations: Speeding, driving under the influence, or failing to stop at a crosswalk may lead to negligence per se in car accident claims.
- Building Code Violations: A landlord failing to install smoke detectors in rental units, as required by law, could be held liable for injuries sustained in a fire.
- Health and Safety Standards: Restaurants violating food safety regulations that result in foodborne illnesses may face negligence per se claims.
- Workplace Safety Breaches: Employers who disregard OSHA (Occupational Safety and Health Administration) guidelines, leading to injuries, may be held negligent per se.
These examples highlight how statutory violations create a shortcut for proving negligence, making it easier for plaintiffs to seek compensation for their injuries.
Key Differences Between Negligence Per Se and Ordinary Negligence
Although negligence per se and ordinary negligence share similarities, they differ in the burden of proof and the type of evidence required:
Burden of Proof:
In ordinary negligence, the plaintiff must demonstrate that the defendant acted unreasonably under the circumstances. In negligence per se, the focus is on whether the defendant violated a specific law.
Evidence:
Ordinary negligence relies on evidence of the defendant's behavior, and negligence per se centers on the legal breach itself.
Applicability:
Negligence per se only applies when a statute is specifically designed to protect individuals from the harm experienced by the plaintiff.
By narrowing the focus to statutory violations, negligence per se reduces the plaintiff's need to prove reasonableness, shifting the discussion to causation and damages.
Legal Defenses Against Negligence Per Se
Defendants in negligence per se cases often argue one of the following defenses to avoid liability:
Inapplicability of the Statute:
The defendant may claim that the statute violated does not apply to the plaintiff or the circumstances of the case.
Lack of Causation:
The defendant will argue that their statutory violation was not the proximate cause of the plaintiff's injury.
Reasonable Excuse:
Certain situations, such as emergencies or circumstances beyond the defendant's control, may justify the statutory violation.
The defendant might assert that the plaintiff's own negligence contributed to their injury, reducing or eliminating the defendant's liability.
Real-World Statistics Highlighting Negligence Per Se
Statistical data illustrates the importance of laws and their role in negligence per se claims. For example:
- Traffic Accidents: Based on information from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), over 40% of traffic accidents are linked to violations of traffic laws, such as speeding or distracted driving.
- Workplace Injuries: OSHA reports that approximately 20% of workplace fatalities in 2022 occurred in the construction industry, with many cases involving violations of safety regulations.
- Foodborne Illnesses: The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) estimates that 48 million Americans suffer from foodborne illnesses annually, often due to breaches of health safety laws.
These statistics highlight how legal violations create significant risks, underscoring the importance of the negligence per se doctrine in addressing such cases.
Practical Implications for Plaintiffs
For individuals pursuing personal injury claims, understanding negligence per se can simplify their case. Key takeaways include:
Evidentiary Simplification:
Plaintiffs don't need to prove the defendant acted unreasonably—demonstrating a statutory violation suffices.
Focus on Causation:
Plaintiffs should be prepared to show how the violation directly caused their injuries.
Legal Guidance:
Since negligence per se involves interpreting statutes, consulting an experienced personal injury attorney is essential for a successful claim.
Conclusion
Negligence per se provides an efficient framework for holding individuals accountable for harm caused by their statutory violations. By focusing on breaches of law, this doctrine helps streamline personal injury claims and ensure victims receive fair compensation. Whether the case involves traffic violations, workplace injuries, or health and safety breaches, negligence per se underscores the importance of following regulations designed to protect public safety.
Need Legal Help? Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law is One Phone Call Away
Navigating Personal Injury Claims can be challenging. Fortunately, you don't need to do it alone. The experienced personal injury lawyers at Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law, are available 24/7 to help you understand your legal options, gather necessary evidence, and build a strong case to secure the settlement you deserve.
Contact us now for a free legal review.