Understanding Pre-Trial Motions in Personal Injury Cases

When pursuing a personal injury lawsuit, you may encounter pre-trial motions—legal requests made to the court before the case goes to trial. These motions can resolve legal disputes early, shape the direction of the case, and sometimes even lead to a resolution without trial. Understanding these motions is important because they can affect the evidence allowed, the arguments made, and whether the case proceeds at all.

Pre-trial motions may be filed by either the plaintiff or the defendant, with each side aiming to strengthen its position before trial. These motions help clarify legal questions, challenge procedural issues, and manage the scope of the case. Below are some of the most common pre-trial motions used in personal injury cases.

Common Types of Pre-Trial Motions in Personal Injury Cases

Motion to Dismiss

A motion to dismiss is typically filed by the defense, arguing that the lawsuit should not proceed for legal reasons. This motion can be granted if:

If granted, the case may be dismissed entirely. However, in some situations, the plaintiff may be allowed to correct and refile the complaint.

Motion for Summary Judgment

A motion for summary judgment is used when one party believes there are no significant factual disputes that require a trial. This motion asks the judge to rule in favor of the moving party based solely on the law.

Defendants use this motion to argue that the plaintiff has insufficient evidence to prove their claim, while plaintiffs may use it to assert that liability is clear, and the court should award damages without proceeding to trial. If granted, summary judgment can end the case without the need for a jury trial.

Motion to Compel

Discovery is the process where both sides exchange evidence and information. If one party refuses to cooperate, the opposing side can file a motion to compel, asking the court to order compliance.

For example, if an insurance company refuses to hand over important documents, the plaintiff’s attorney can file a motion to compel, ensuring access to relevant information. This helps prevent one side from withholding critical evidence.

Motion in Limine

A motion in limine seeks to prevent certain evidence from being presented at trial. The purpose is to exclude evidence that is irrelevant, prejudicial, or unreliable.

Examples include:

  • Attempts to introduce unrelated prior injuries of the plaintiff.
  • A defendant’s past legal history that is not relevant to the case.
  • Witness testimony that lacks credibility or proper foundation.

Winning a motion in limine can help ensure a fair trial by focusing only on admissible and relevant evidence.

Motion for Change of Venue

A motion for change of venue requests the trial to be moved to another location. This is typically requested when:

  • A local jury may be biased due to media coverage or community influence.
  • The case was filed in a jurisdiction that is inconvenient for witnesses and parties involved.

If granted, the case will be heard in a different court that may be more neutral or convenient.

How Pre-Trial Motions Can Affect Your Case

Pre-trial motions play a major role in shaping how a personal injury case unfolds. Depending on the court’s rulings, they can:

  • Streamline the trial process by resolving legal questions early.
  • Remove weak claims or defenses, saving time and resources.
  • Exclude prejudicial evidence, ensuring a fair trial.
  • Encourage settlements, especially if one party gains a legal advantage.

Because these motions can significantly impact a case, having an experienced attorney handle them properly is important.

Why You Need a Personal Injury Attorney for Pre-Trial Motions

Handling pre-trial motions requires legal expertise, strategic thinking, and thorough knowledge of procedural rules. An experienced personal injury attorney will:

  • Draft and respond to motions effectively to strengthen your case.
  • Ensure full discovery compliance, filing motions when necessary.
  • Challenge improper motions from the opposing party to protect your claim.
  • Negotiate settlements leveraging favorable court rulings.

Having skilled legal representation ensures you are prepared for every stage of the pre-trial process and maximizes your chances of success.

Call Brandon J. Broderick for Legal Help

If you’re dealing with a personal injury claim, having a knowledgeable attorney on your side is important. At Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law, we have experience handling personal injury cases. Our team is committed to protecting your rights and securing the best possible outcome for your case.

Contact us today for a free consultation.

Still have questions?

Call now and be done