When dealing with a personal injury claim in Pennsylvania, it’s common to feel frustration or disappointment when the first settlement offer from an insurance company seems unreasonably low. Understanding the reasoning behind these initial offers can empower you to negotiate more effectively and advocate for the compensation you truly deserve. Below, we explore five reasons why your first settlement offer may be low, providing insights into the claims process and strategies to strengthen your position.

1. Insurance Companies Prioritize Profit

Insurance companies operate as businesses, and their primary goal is to minimize payouts and protect their bottom line. The adjuster handling your case may deliberately make a lowball offer to test whether you’re willing to settle quickly and cheaply.

This tactic is often referred to as “anchoring,” where an insurer sets the stage for negotiations with a low offer, hoping you’ll accept it out of frustration or financial need. Keep in mind that adjusters are skilled negotiators trained to exploit your lack of experience with personal injury claims. Knowing their strategy can help you remain patient and negotiate effectively.

2. Incomplete Medical Documentation

A lack of complete and thorough medical documentation can lead to undervaluation of your claim. If your injuries, treatments, or long-term prognosis are not adequately documented, the insurance company may argue that your damages are minor or speculative.

For example, Pennsylvania law requires claimants to provide evidence of medical bills, ongoing treatments, and any future medical needs tied to the accident. If your initial submission omits critical records—such as physical therapy sessions or projected surgery costs—the adjuster will use this as a reason to lower the offer.

Tip: Work with your healthcare provider to ensure every aspect of your injury is documented, including diagnoses, treatment plans, and any expected recovery timeline.

3. Disputed Liability

If the insurance company questions liability in your case, they will likely present a reduced settlement offer. Pennsylvania follows a modified comparative negligence rule, which means your compensation may be reduced if you’re found partially at fault for the accident. If you’re deemed more than 50% responsible, you may not recover any damages at all.

Disputed liability allows insurers to argue that your claim’s value is lower than you believe. For instance, if an accident occurred at an intersection, the insurance company might argue that you contributed to the crash by speeding or failing to yield.

Solution: Gather evidence such as photographs, witness statements, police reports, and, if possible, video footage to support your case. A strong liability argument can discourage insurers from undervaluing your claim.

4. Initial Offers Exclude Non-Economic Damages

First settlement offers often fail to account for non-economic damages such as pain and suffering, emotional distress, or diminished quality of life. These intangible losses can significantly impact the overall value of your claim, especially in cases involving severe or permanent injuries.

For example, a car accident victim in Pennsylvania might be offered compensation only for medical bills and lost wages, with no acknowledgment of the emotional toll or long-term impact of their injuries. This oversight is deliberate, as insurers know these damages can be challenging to quantify and require skilled negotiation or litigation to secure.

Actionable Advice: Work with an experienced personal injury attorney to calculate non-economic damages and present a compelling case that highlights the emotional and physical impact of your injuries.

5. Pressure to Settle Quickly

Insurance companies know that injured claimants are often under financial strain, especially when faced with mounting medical bills and lost income. They may exploit this vulnerability by offering a quick, low settlement in hopes you’ll accept before consulting an attorney or fully assessing your damages.

This tactic is especially common in Pennsylvania, where victims may not realize the full extent of their injuries or losses immediately after an accident. Accepting an early offer could mean forfeiting your right to pursue additional compensation if your condition worsens or unexpected expenses arise.

Pro Tip: Resist the urge to settle quickly. Take the time to consult a personal injury attorney and assess the long-term impact of your injuries. An attorney can help you accurately value your claim and negotiate with the insurance company for a fair settlement.

How to Strengthen Your Claim

To counteract low settlement offers, consider these steps:

• Hire a Personal Injury Lawyer: Attorneys understand Pennsylvania’s legal landscape and can negotiate on your behalf, often securing higher settlements than claimants achieve alone.
• Document Everything: Maintain thorough records of medical treatments, lost wages, property damage, and out-of-pocket expenses. These documents are vital in demonstrating the true value of your claim.
• Be Patient: Settlement negotiations take time. Don’t rush to accept an offer before fully understanding your rights and the potential value of your case.
• Demand Justification: Ask the insurance company to explain how they arrived at their initial offer. This can help you identify areas where your claim is undervalued and respond with counter-evidence.

Conclusion

Receiving a low first settlement offer can feel discouraging, but it’s important to remember that it’s only the starting point in a negotiation process. By understanding the reasons behind lowball offers and taking proactive steps to strengthen your case, you can advocate for the compensation you deserve. In Pennsylvania, where personal injury claims can be complex, working with an experienced attorney can significantly improve your chances of achieving a fair and just settlement.

Need Legal Help? Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law is One Phone Call Away

Navigating Pennsylvania Personal Injury claims can be challenging. Fortunately, you don't need to do it alone. The experienced lawyers at Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law, are available 24/7 to help you understand your legal options, gather necessary evidence, and build a strong case to secure the settlement you deserve.

Contact us now for a free legal review.