New York construction companies face some of the highest insurance premiums in the nation. This is a significant financial burden for businesses already navigating complex regulatory requirements and labor costs. Several factors contribute to these high premiums, but one of the most pivotal is New York's Scaffold Law (Labor Law 240/241). Understanding the causes behind these costs and how companies can mitigate them is essential for staying competitive in the New York construction industry.

The Scaffold Law and Its Impact on Insurance Costs

New York's Scaffold Law, enacted in 1885, was designed to protect workers from injuries related to falls from heights. Under this law, contractors and property owners are held strictly liable for gravity-related accidents, such as falls or objects falling on workers. This strict liability means that if a worker is injured due to a fall, the employer or contractor is automatically responsible for damages, regardless of whether the worker was at fault.

While the law was initially intended to increase safety standards on construction sites, its long-term impact has been a dramatic increase in litigation and settlement costs. Insurance companies view New York construction companies as high-risk due to the increased likelihood of expensive lawsuits. Consequently, they charge significantly higher premiums to cover potential losses.

Key Effects of the Scaffold Law:

• Strict liability: Employers cannot defend against claims by arguing that the worker was at fault, even if they failed to follow safety protocols.
• Expensive lawsuits: Settlements and judgments under the Scaffold Law can reach millions of dollars, leading insurers to pass these costs onto businesses in the form of higher premiums.
• Higher deductibles: In addition to increased premiums, construction companies may face larger deductibles due to the risk involved in operating under the Scaffold Law.

New York's Unique Position in the Insurance Market

One of the reasons insurance premiums are higher for New York construction companies than for those in other states is that New York is the only state with a law like the Scaffold Law. This makes the insurance market in New York unique, as insurers must price their policies to account for potential litigation under the law. Construction businesses in neighboring states do not face the same level of liability risk, which translates to lower insurance premiums for companies outside New York.

• Comparison with Other States: In states like New Jersey and Pennsylvania, where contributory negligence applies, both workers and employers share responsibility for safety on job sites. This shared liability lowers the potential for large settlements, reducing insurance premiums for construction companies in those states.
• Industry statistics: According to the New York Compensation Insurance Rating Board, contractors in New York pay insurance premiums that are, on average, 5-10 times higher than those in neighboring states, primarily because of the Scaffold Law.

The Role of Worker Compensation Claims

Another driver of high insurance premiums for construction companies in New York is the number of worker compensation claims. The construction industry is inherently dangerous, with heavy machinery, elevated structures, and hazardous materials increasing the risk of injury. Even without the Scaffold Law, the frequency of worker compensation claims is higher in construction than in many other industries, leading to inflated insurance costs.

Common Injuries in Construction:

• Falls from heights: As one of the leading causes of injuries on construction sites, these incidents are directly linked to the Scaffold Law.
• Struck by objects: Falling tools, materials, or debris can cause significant injuries, triggering costly claims.
• Repetitive motion injuries: These may not result in large settlements, but they add to the overall number of claims a company faces, further increasing insurance premiums.

How Construction Companies Can Lower Insurance Premiums

Despite the challenges posed by the Scaffold Law and the inherent risks of the construction industry, there are steps companies can take to manage insurance premiums. Implementing rigorous safety protocols and regularly training workers on safe practices can help reduce the number of accidents and claims.

• Safety training: Regular safety training is one of the most effective ways to lower the risk of accidents on construction sites. When workers are trained to follow best practices, such as wearing proper safety gear and adhering to OSHA standards, the likelihood of costly injuries decreases.
• Comprehensive risk assessments: By conducting regular risk assessments and addressing potential hazards before they lead to accidents, companies can demonstrate to insurers that they are proactive about safety. This can result in lower premiums.
• Work with specialized brokers: Some insurance brokers specialize in construction-related policies. These brokers can often negotiate better rates for companies, particularly if they can demonstrate a track record of safe operations.

Legislative Efforts and Industry Advocacy

There has been a growing call from construction industry groups to reform or repeal the Scaffold Law, arguing that it unfairly penalizes employers. Industry advocates propose a more balanced approach, where comparative negligence would allow courts to assign a percentage of fault to workers who contribute to their own injuries.

• Proposed reforms: Some lawmakers and industry groups have pushed for legislation that would amend the Scaffold Law to allow for contributory negligence, similar to what exists in most other states. Despite these efforts, labor unions and worker advocacy groups have opposed such changes, asserting that the law offers vital protections for construction workers.
• Economic impact: Reform advocates claim that the Scaffold Law increases not only insurance costs but also the overall cost of construction projects. This makes New York less competitive for large-scale developments and infrastructure projects, ultimately harming the state's economy.

Conclusion

Insurance premiums for construction companies in New York are some of the highest in the nation, largely due to the state's Scaffold Law. While the law was enacted to protect workers, its strict liability provisions have led to increased litigation and insurance costs. Construction companies can take steps to manage these costs through safety protocols, risk assessments, and working with specialized brokers. However, meaningful reductions in premiums will likely require legislative reform to balance the interests of both workers and employers.

Need Legal Help? Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law is One Phone Call Away

Navigating New York construction accident claims can be challenging. Fortunately, you don't need to do it alone. The experienced personal injury lawyers at Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law, are available 24/7 to help you understand your legal options, gather necessary evidence, and build a strong case to secure the settlement you deserve.

Contact us now for a free legal review.