Building collapses are catastrophic events that result in severe injuries, loss of life, and extensive property damage. These incidents trigger investigations into what caused the collapse and who bears responsibility. In New Jersey, determining liability involves examining various factors, including negligence, construction practices, and regulatory compliance. Multiple parties can be held accountable depending on the situation. Below is an overview of key players and scenarios where liability might arise, as well as actionable steps for victims seeking compensation.

Common Causes of Building Collapses

To determine liability, it’s essential to understand what causes these structural failures. Below are common factors that lead to building collapses:

• Defective Materials: Low-quality construction materials or faulty equipment can cause a building’s structural components to fail prematurely.
• Design Flaws: Architectural errors or improper load calculations may result in unsafe structures.
• Negligent Construction Practices: Builders cutting corners by ignoring safety standards or rushing to complete projects increase the risk of collapse.
• Poor Maintenance: Property owners who neglect building inspections, repairs, or upkeep can be held accountable for structural degradation.
• Natural Disasters: Earthquakes, flooding, or hurricanes may compromise building foundations, especially if developers failed to adhere to disaster-resistant construction codes.

Parties That May Be Liable for a Building Collapse

In New Jersey, identifying liable parties requires understanding who had a role in the building’s construction, maintenance, or safety oversight. Depending on the circumstances, liability could rest on one or multiple parties. Here’s a breakdown of key potential defendants:

1. Property Owners
   • Owners are generally responsible for ensuring their buildings remain safe for occupants and visitors. If inspections or repairs were not conducted regularly or known hazards were ignored, the property owner could face liability.
   • For example, if an apartment complex owner ignores tenant complaints about structural cracks, they could be held liable if the building collapses.
2. Construction Companies and Contractors
   • Builders and subcontractors must adhere to construction standards and codes. If poor craftsmanship or shortcuts during construction led to a collapse, they could be held accountable.
   • Subcontractors may also bear liability if they supplied defective materials or improperly installed components.
3. Architects and Engineers
   • Architects and engineers play an important role in designing and approving building plans. If design flaws or miscalculations contributed to the failure, these professionals may be liable for the resulting damages.
   • New Jersey requires engineers to certify their work, meaning errors on their part could directly implicate them in liability claims.
4. Material Suppliers and Manufacturers
   • If defective materials were a factor in the collapse, liability may extend to the manufacturers or suppliers who provided faulty products.
   • Examples include using subpar concrete or steel that fails to meet regulatory standards, leading to weakened structures.
5. Municipalities and Government Agencies
   • In some cases, local governments can be held liable if improper inspections or inadequate enforcement of safety codes contributed to a building collapse.
   • New Jersey law does, however, provide government entities with limited immunity, making these cases challenging but not impossible to pursue.

Legal Theories Used in Building Collapse Cases

In building collapse lawsuits, several legal principles are commonly applied to establish liability:

• Negligence: To prove negligence, the injured party needs to demonstrate that the defendant owed a duty of care, breached that duty, and caused the damages through their actions or failure to act.
• Product Liability: If defective materials caused the collapse, the victim may file a product liability claim against the manufacturer or supplier. New Jersey law follows strict liability for defective products, meaning negligence does not need to be proven to hold manufacturers accountable.
• Premises Liability: When an owner fails to maintain their building adequately, injured parties can pursue compensation under premises liability laws. This theory applies when building owners neglect their duty to maintain a safe environment.

Statute of Limitations for Building Collapse Lawsuits in NJ

New Jersey law imposes specific time limits for filing lawsuits related to personal injury or property damage caused by building collapses:

• Personal Injury and Wrongful Death Claims: Victims have two years from the date of injury or death to file a claim.
• Property Damage Claims: If the collapse caused property damage, the owner has six years to pursue compensation.
• Claims Against Government Entities: If a government agency is involved, a notice of claim needs to be filed within 90 days under the New Jersey Tort Claims Act.

It’s essential to act quickly to meet these deadlines, as failure to do so can result in the case being dismissed.

Compensation Available to Victims

Victims of building collapses may seek several types of compensation, including:

• Medical Expenses: Coverage for surgeries, rehabilitation, or long-term care for injuries sustained in the collapse.
• Lost Wages: Compensation for income lost due to the inability to work during recovery.
• Pain and Suffering: Victims can claim damages for emotional distress, trauma, and the physical pain endured from injuries.
• Property Damage: If personal belongings or real estate were destroyed, victims could pursue reimbursement.
• Punitive Damages: In cases where the defendant’s conduct was reckless or egregious, courts might award punitive damages to deter future negligence.

Preventing Building Collapses: Lessons Learned

Building collapses, such as the 2021 Surfside condo disaster in Florida, serve as harsh reminders of the importance of strict safety protocols. New Jersey has taken steps to tighten its building codes and inspection requirements, but vigilance is essential. Developers, contractors, and property owners must prioritize safety over cost-cutting to avoid preventable tragedies.

Conclusion

Liability for building collapses in New Jersey can fall on several parties, such as property owners, contractors, architects, or even government agencies. For victims and their families, figuring out who is responsible and getting compensation can feel overwhelming. If you’ve been injured or experienced loss from a building collapse, it’s important to reach out to a personal injury attorney. 

Need Legal Help? Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law is One Phone Call Away

Navigating New Jersey personal injury claims can be challenging. Fortunately, you don't need to do it alone. The experienced Personal Injury Lawyers at Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law, are available 24/7 to help you understand your legal options, gather necessary evidence, and build a strong case to secure the settlement you deserve.

Contact us now for a free legal review.