In Florida, personal injury cases often involve more than just the victim’s physical injuries. When someone is seriously hurt due to another party’s negligence, the impact frequently extends to the victim’s family, especially spouses. One of the less-discussed but important types of damages available in Florida is loss of consortium. This type of claim recognizes the emotional, relational, and sometimes financial losses that a spouse may suffer when their partner sustains a debilitating injury. Here’s an in-depth look at loss of consortium in Florida personal injury cases and what it means for families seeking justice.

What is Loss of Consortium?

Loss of consortium is a legal claim that allows a spouse to seek damages for the loss of companionship, affection, and support that an injured partner provided before the accident. This claim is based on the idea that a serious injury impacts not only the individual who was hurt but also the quality of the relationship they share with their spouse. Loss of consortium claims are typically filed alongside the primary personal injury lawsuit.

Key aspects covered by loss of consortium damages include:

• Emotional Support: Injuries that limit a partner’s ability to offer emotional support can have a profound effect on the spouse.
• Physical Intimacy: Loss of physical closeness, including sexual relations, due to injury or pain.
• Household Contributions: Assistance with household chores, parenting, and family management.
• Loss of Companionship: The inability to engage in shared activities, hobbies, or interests.

Legal Requirements for a Loss of Consortium Claim in Florida

To successfully claim loss of consortium in Florida, the plaintiff must meet certain legal criteria. Unlike some other states, Florida limits these claims to married spouses only. The state does not allow parents, children, or unmarried partners to claim loss of consortium, though parents may have separate rights under wrongful death statutes in specific cases.

Elements of a Valid Loss of Consortium Claim in Florida:

1. Proof of a Marital Relationship: The couple must have been legally married at the time of the injury.
2. Severity of Injury: The injury must be severe enough to significantly impact the marital relationship.
3. Direct Impact on Relationship: Evidence that the injury has directly affected the marriage, reducing the injured party’s ability to provide companionship, intimacy, or support.

Calculating Loss of Consortium Damages

Loss of consortium damages can be difficult to quantify. Unlike medical expenses or lost income, which have a clear economic value, these damages are non-economic and based on emotional, social, and relational losses. Florida courts consider several factors when determining an appropriate award for loss of consortium, including the couple’s relationship history, the nature and extent of the injury, and the impact on the marital relationship.

Factors affecting the calculation of loss of consortium damages:

• Duration of the Marriage: Courts often view longer marriages as having deeper emotional and relational bonds, which may impact the compensation awarded.
• Severity and Permanency of Injury: Permanent or life-altering injuries generally result in higher awards for loss of consortium.
• Age and Health of the Spouse: The age and health of both spouses can influence the damages awarded, as it impacts the loss over time.

In Florida, non-economic damages in personal injury cases are not capped, allowing loss of consortium claims to be assessed individually based on the specific circumstances of each case.

Challenges in Proving Loss of Consortium

Loss of consortium claims face several challenges in court. Given the subjective nature of the damages, proving the extent of relational loss can be complex. Additionally, defense attorneys often argue against these claims, attempting to minimize or refute the emotional and relational impact described.

Common obstacles in loss of consortium claims include:

• Subjectivity: Unlike economic losses, loss of consortium damages are non-tangible, making them more difficult to prove.
• Defense Arguments: Defense attorneys may claim that the marriage was already strained or that the injury did not significantly impact the relationship.
• Need for Personal Testimonies: Spouses often need to provide detailed, personal testimonies, which can be challenging for some.

Steps to Strengthen a Loss of Consortium Claim

While loss of consortium claims can be challenging, there are strategies to build a strong case. Working with an experienced personal injury lawyer can be invaluable for gathering evidence and presenting the claim convincingly.

Actions to take for a stronger loss of consortium claim:

• Collect Evidence: Photographs, messages, and medical records that demonstrate the injury’s impact on daily life.
• Testimony from Family and Friends: Statements from close family or friends can provide insight into how the injury has affected the marital relationship.
• Use of Expert Witnesses: A therapist or psychologist may be able to explain the injury’s emotional impact on the couple.

Conclusion

Loss of consortium claims highlight the far-reaching impact of serious injuries on family dynamics, emphasizing that injuries do not only affect the physical well-being of the victim but also alter their relationships. For spouses seeking compensation, a loss of consortium claim can provide some measure of relief and validation. By working with a skilled attorney, families can better navigate the complex legal landscape of loss of consortium claims and strive to restore the quality of life disrupted by a serious injury.

Need Legal Help? Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law is One Phone Call Away

Navigating Florida personal injury claims can be challenging. Fortunately, you don't need to do it alone. The experienced personal injury lawyers at Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law, are available 24/7 to help you understand your legal options, gather necessary evidence, and build a strong case to secure the settlement you deserve. 

Contact us now for a free legal review.